Ned: Die with Honor Blog Post
Ned:
Die with Honor Blog Post
Ned Stark’s actions and thoughts are motivated by a moral
code of honor throughout his whole life up until right before his death. Throughout
his whole life, viewers have been very critical whether Ned is just plain
stupid or if he is just acting on his honor and standards that he has set for
himself. I believe that Ned is one honorable man that wants the best for
everyone whether he has known you for five minutes or twenty years. Yet despite
Ned’s well intentions, there is a fine balance between respecting your honor
and being blind to what is happening around you. In fact, sometimes I think
that Ned just lacks an attention to detail and that is where is honor fails
him. Even if Ned’s lack of perception ends up costing him his head, I believe
that it is better to die being an honorable man than dying while being a snake.
Throughout
the television series Ned believes that it is better to die an honorable man
than to sacrifice the honorable code he lives by. There are many characters
throughout the seasons who act in very prideful ways even though they believe
it is the “honorable” thing to do in their mind. I often feel as if there is a
misconception between the terms honor and pride. Google
says the definition of honor is having high respect and an adherence to what is
right. Google
also says the definition of pride is a feeling of satisfaction derived from
one’s own achievements or from qualities or possessions that are widely
admired. I think people often mix up these two terms and end up thinking they
are the same thing. Ned is honorable deep in his soul, while as characters like
Cersei and Tywin are very prideful. Ned was even willing to confess to a crime
his didn’t commit in order to protect his family and his people. If Ned was
prideful, he wouldn’t have confessed into doing any crimes. Tywin is a good
example of someone who is very prideful in the series. He believes that anyone
that doesn’t look at his house with anything other than admiration and fear he
absolutely can’t tolerate them. He acts with violence because he lets his pride
get the best of him resulting in harsh and reckless actions and or consequences.
Cersei is also another example of a character that is prideful. She is prideful
in that aspect that she is even willing to have the old hand of the King killed
in order to protect her messed up family and name. As you can see, there are
clear distinct differences between these two terms. Ned is very honorable and
should be viewed that way instead of being criticized.
Even though many viewers think Ned is honorable, some
still think that he makes stupid decisions. They believe he makes these bad
decisions because he has these honor blinders on to where he can only see the
honorable thing to do and no other options. Harold
Lake
concludes that Ned was so obsessed with being honorable that he didn’t
understand when he would cross the stupid line. I would have to agree with his
point since Ned would sometimes act in a way that wouldn’t make any sense
unless you had that amount of honor inside of you. For example, telling Cersei that
he knew about her messing around with her own brother was not a very
intelligent decision of his part. Another dumb mistake he did was trusting
Littlefinger as much as he did, without checking out what type of person he has
been. Ned often believed that everyone was going to do the honorable and
trustworthy thing in life. While it is good to think that, he fails to realize
that most people are selfish and greedy for themselves. Even with these stupid
decisions Ned made, it is still better to be honorable than be fake and a snake
throughout one’s life.
Ned is a man defined by his sense of honor and duty.
These honors and duties he had incorporated in his life have either been
traditions or things that have come down from many generations. For example,
one of the first scenes in the series includes Ned capturing a deserter from
the Night’s Watch. Everyone knows that the punishment for doing such a crime is
death especially Ned. The law is the law in Ned’s mind and therefore it can’t
be broken or bent for any reason or else it would be breaking his honor code. He
also tried to lead by example and be in the action in most things that he does
within his life. You can tell that Ned is honorable in this scene since he
won’t bend any of the rules and he also takes the sword and carries out the
death himself, instead of getting someone else to do the act. Another instance
where Ned is honorable and must do the act himself is in the scene with the
dire wolf. Since Arya was “misbehaving” the wolf that “attacked” Joffery was
missing, then the conclusion they came up with was to kill the other one that
they had obtained. Ned acts in an honorable way by putting the dire wolf to
sleep instead of having someone else kill it in vein. This is important because
Ned acts like he has a softer spot in his heart with mercy for certain things
which can be both a good and bad thing. However, most of the other houses do
not have a lot of mercy for anyone other than themselves and this hurt Ned in
the long run. Even with Ned having mercy, Ned acts in honorable ways in both
scenes and there is no sense of weakness coming from him.
Throughout
the series, Ned proves time and time again that he acts in honorable ways the
majority of the time. For example, Ned was very honorable in the way that he
confronted Cersei about her affair after figuring out the truth behind her
children. Ned could have just kept his mouth shut and went along with his life,
but his honor took over. Ned thought he would have the upper hand when telling
Cersei, the news that he knew. However, Cersei and Tywin don’t have honor and
therefore don’t play by the same rules that Ned does. I am not sure that Ned
thought of all the possible scenarios that could happen resulting from telling
her the news. Once again, Ned had that honor part in his heart, and I think he
thought that he couldn’t live with himself if he didn’t try and do something
about the discovery he found. I do believe that he still could have been
honorable within himself if he didn’t tell Cersei and just want straight to
Stannis. I believe if Ned went with this decision then the whole series would
have shift and Ned would have also lived a lot longer than by just going
straight to Cersei. Another example of
Ned being honorable would be when he wants to put the rightful heir in the
throne instead of the person that people think should go on the throne. Ned
doesn’t want to consider putting someone else in the place of the rightful heir
even if it means a better life for himself and his family. Ned’s honor
sometimes puts blinders on him and as a result, he digs his hole deeper and
deeper. I appreciate the fact that Ned is willing to stand up for what he
believes in (honor) but sometimes by disagreeing with the majority comes with a
cost. In my opinion, Ned was comfortable by standing by his honor and duties to
do what is right even if that meant his life was in danger. If no harm would be
done to his family, especially his girls, then Ned would do what he thought was
right. I even thought it was honorable that he was willing to confess to crimes
he didn’t even commit to protect his family and people. In these examples, you
can clearly see that Ned is doing the work of an honorable man even if that is
the hard thing to do at that moment and for that I commend him.
Even by looking at Ned’s death you can tell that he was
honorable and someone that the people liked and respected. Despite people slaying
his name and accusing him of all these bad things like being a traitor, Ned
still had quite the impact on many people. Andrew
Sawyer stated that by his love and loyalty he had earned
throughout the years, he had the entire North wanting to revolt against the Kingdom
itself. This is a powerful effect of Ned’s death since everyone is now willing
to give their lives up to avenge the death of Ned. If you ask me, what more of
a way to honor the “honorable man” but by giving your own life for someone
else. Ned set the example of what it was like to live an honorable life and set
the example to the upcoming generation to follow.
In conclusion, even though many viewers see Ned as being
dumb and stupid, he is an honorable man who is willing to give up his life in
order to do what is right. Moving forward in the show, I believe that the North
will always remember what honor Ned stood for with his life. Ned held all his
traditions, principles and loyalties all the way to the end and I commend him
for doing that especially with all the difficulties he faced along the way. Ned
will always be honorable in my eyes because I believe that it is better to die
with honor than by dying a snake’s life while resulting in a person you weren’t
proud to be.
Ned was a very honorable man and maintaining that honor was one of his biggest concerns and I agree that this mindset is what determined his death in the series. He was too concerned with keeping his image clean and doing what was right that the other characters like Cersei saw this as a weak point. They knew that they could get to him by going after one of the things he cared about most and that was his honor. I like the comment you make about how viewers believe that he has honor blinders on, this really brings out how serious he was about keeping his honor intact.
ReplyDelete-Mary
I do not believe that he was trying to keep his image clean, but to preserve his morals and values. Like what Nick said about Ned having blinders on really functions here. You are correct in you stating that Cersei and others saw Ned as weak for holding honor above pride.
DeleteI believe it was significant that Dany started out being a loved character and Cersei being hated because there would be quite a flip at the end of season two. They wanted an emphasis on how people are able to change, whether it being good or bad.
ReplyDeleteBoth of these females showed power, Cersei through her sexuality and ultimately Dany through her dragons. Additionally, I thought it was very insightful to look at how the loss of a husband affected both of these characters. Dany became very power hungry while Cersei was trying to have some type of control over her son. Thus far, both of these women are indirectly compared to each other which makes everything more interesting.
-Amber
I agree with you as to the fact that Ned is to be known as an honorable man instead of being confused with the term of prideful. Ned took the term honor to a whole different motive than other characters in GOT as he did what he had to do in order to in order to try to protect his family and his people. He did not let his pride get into his head like Cersei for example who only really cares about herself. Although Ned does make some foolish decisions, like when he confronted Cersei about her affair with her twin brother. He could have easily avoided saying that to her, but I agree with you statement that his sense of honor took over him and he should not in anyway be criticized for it.
ReplyDeleteI wonder what would have become of Ned Stark if he was still alive throughout the show. Would he have stayed alive a little longer? Would the world around him change his view? Would he have stayed honorable or became more prideful? What if he learned the distinction between knowing when to pay attention to little details and when to keep his mouth close?
ReplyDelete