HOW
FOOLISH CAN NED STARK BE?
Although the world Ned
Stark lives in is filled with colors and ambiguity, why does he only see in
black and white? Yes of course this may have been a time where people like Ned
Stark were taught differently and raised to think a different way than we may
think now. However, I’m sure the world was still just as colorful and
complicated as the one we live in now. Real world situations aren’t just black
and White, but more of a “ROGYBV” type of affair.
I mean, come on, let’s
just start by saying “Hand to the King” sounds like a job suitable for a kiss
ass, a teacher’s pet, a suck up, a snitch… however else you may choose to look
at it. It’s supposed to be a job for the second most powerful man in the
kingdom, but it’s more
like a patsy for the highest bidder. All of which could
put Ned in the running for hand to the king, seeing as how he follows all the
rules. Many people forget about his loyalty for the job, however, consider his
good qualities. Jeni writes, “I think he was just true
to himself. He never varied from what he thought was right. He ‘walked the walk,’ so to speak.”
Which is true he did walk the way he talked, but at what cost? Following the
rules isn’t always the best choice, which Ned discovered later through the
series.
For instance, the boy of
the Night’s Watch Ned kills in the first episode by beheading had a pretty good
reason for running from the wall. A young boy sees people he knows get their
heads cut off by what seems like an oversized bride of Chuckie doll in the
woods, and they expect him to not run and not be scared? Come on. And instead
of being honorable and understanding where the boy was coming from, Ned was
more of a wannabe manager at the job you hate who alway’s yelling, THIS IS
POLICY! Seeing things one-sided instead of recognizing the complexity of the
world. Okay, Karen, I mean, Lord Eddard.
And not to mention the
conversation between Catelyn, Ned, and Maester Lewin when Lysa Arryn wrote
them. Brother-in-law Ned had to make a decision to be Hand of the King or stay with
his family. it's
worth noting that numerous individuals warned the Lord of Winterfell not to
bark up the Baratheon-Lannister family tree. But he was dead set in his noble
ways, Catelyn makes a good argument when she states that
Ned has already fought for Robert long enough. Yet Ned sees in black and White, so he
automatically determines that he needs to protect Robert. This decision doesn’t
seem too honorable when you consider that his family is on the line. Endangering
your life for a man who already told you he wants you to run his kingdoms while
he parties—yes, Robert literally said that—doesn’t seem to be the honorable choice
for your family, who should come before anything.
Shit is already starting
to hit the fan, and Ned isn’t even at Kings Landing yet. Although Ned was
aggravated and in total disbelief with Robert when his daughter went missing
after fighting with Prince Joffrey, and Robert acted as if it was Arya’s fault.
And when it comes down to decision-making time the king orders Lady to be put
down just to make his bad-tempered wife happy… instead of standing up for what
he knew was right, the oh-so-obedient Ned Stark followed through with commands.
The irony in the scene itself is quite funny. A man who is just as obedient and
loyal as the very dog he has to kill. Just as innocent and what seems to be
just as submissive to authority. Even though some might argue that the wolf had
twice as much heart as the man who killed her.
Although even in this era,
there were people that knew that there were many ways and one solution was not
the only answer. They saw that you can’t handle every situation with one simple
solution. For example, when little finger and Ned were discussing the options
that Ned had when becoming hand to the king. Little finger expressed that a
good option would be to marry Auria to Joffrey and raise him as a son to be a
good king to serve under ed didn’t take the advice, he didn’t see that as being
honorable he saw it as being manipulative and sneaky. Not realizing it could
have ben a good deal for not only him but, his family as well. And maybe even
the seven kingdoms.
But did Ned Stark know that at one point his
one view might become his downfall?
Now let’s not forget the
strong conversation between the king and Ned Stark…yes, the one where Stark is
told to kill Daenerys and her child. At this point Ned spoke up about his honor
and how it will go against his morals. And for a minute we all thought, OH WOW
Ned grew a pair and stoop up for what he believes in. Quickly packing his kids
and ready to escape the king’s yes man team. If we’re discussing rather Ned
Stark is honorable this may have been one of the only times, he’s showed honor.
Unfortunately, it didn’t
last long. I guess one sword through the knee and a dead friend is more than
enough to make a grown man step in line. Ned coming back to his one-track ways,
got his pen back, and fell back into place in the king’s men. It almost makes
you wonder; will this be the turning point for Ned? Will he finally see the
world for what it is? And not just some cause and effect flash cards from fifth
grade.
When Ned first discovered
that King Robert’s son Joffrey was not the right heir to the throne and that
Joffrey wasn’t even Robert’s son. This led Ned to figure out why his son Bran
was bedridden. Ned figures out that his son saw the incest between Ceresi and
her brother Jamie. Ned underestimates Cersei by threatening her with the truth
of her second relationship to king Robert. Ned not believing that a woman’s
wrath can be just as powerful as a mans show’s his looks on gender roles. He’s
seeing her as a woman who would not pose a threat, however Cerise is much more
than that. Angel wrote “ Cersei’s
weakness comes not from her gender, but from her lack of natural political
savvy. She’s incredibly ambitious, strong willed, and determined,“
By underestimating how powerful Cerise was he assumed that she would be scared
and would run. Instead it backfired on him in the worst possible way.
His own death. How ironic
is that?
That Following what he
thought was his most honorable self turned out to be the same thing that gets
him killed. He didn’t want to bow down and swear his loyalty to a child I mean
who would…right? The man composed a false confession for treason “ I plotted to
murder his son... and seize the throne for myself. Let the High Septon and
Baelor the Blessed bear witness to what I've said. Joffrey Baratheon... is the
one true heir to the Iron Throne.” Stated by Ned Stark. Although it didn’t help
his case any he did once say his honor meant more than his life.
Not to just bash Ned for
being who he is. we
must give Ned credit for being an idealist. He was a man who lived by a set of
rules and codes, and never switched up no matter what the situation was.
If anything Ned Stark was loyal, truthful, brave, and a man of his word. But he
also is missing a head.
I genuinely enjoyed reading this blog post. The ideas you presented to support your argument were well structured and thought out. The way at which you connected our worlds with the comparison between Eddard and the boss no one likes was different way to think of it but very brilliant. Overall, I was very engaged while reading this piece. Something that was noticeable was the occasional spelling errors throughout the paper. However, this did not affect your argument or ideas. In the future, more attention to detail would improve your papers even more.
ReplyDeleteI absolutely love the title, I think it really ties in to how you feel about Ned and the decisions he made even before making it to the capital. Your ideas were well put together and you had an good argument throughout the paper. Although I do disagree with him not being honorable in a lot of what he did. Going to King's Landing to be hand of the King was honorable because he has always been at the Kings side and telling the truth was also honorable. To me, he only did what he thought best out of honor, but that does not mean he was right to do so. Like you said, he is also missing a head.
ReplyDeleteClearly, Ned Stark is very foolish and thinks everyone has the same honor and integrity that he did. You would think that he would have started to understand how things worked around there after he had to kill Sansa's wolf because of Joffrey. You can't trust people who have too much power and Ned didn't understand that. He let his honor get in the way of his life.
ReplyDeleteAnyways, I really enjoyed reading your blog and how engaged and honest you were while writing it.