Sansa Stark’s Role as Women
Sansa Stark. Why does everyone hate
her? She is hated because she meets societies explanation of a woman. She is
hated because she is caught up in girly things and as Rhiannon states in her
post “In
Defense of Sansa Stark – Feminist Fiction”, “the viewers have been
taught that “girly” is automatically bad.” This is a misogynistic time period
and as a woman in this time period they are expected to wear long dresses, look
pretty, and have children. Sansa behaves exactly like this and as a result she
is the most loved character in the book yet, the most hated in the real world.
The hatred towards Sansa is honestly
unnecessary, because all she knows is that women are supposed to wear long
beautiful dresses, look pretty 24/7, and have children. She does not deserve to
be hated because it her it is her role as women in book and it is her prerogative
as a human being to carry herself in a manner that works for her. Sansa based
her future off the fairy tales she was told, so shouldn’t we really be angry at
the sexist expectations of her society instead of her? She expects to marry a
king so she can be his beautiful queen and carry his princes and princesses.
Because she fits into this role she is seen as “weak,
manipulative, stupid, and generally inferior.”, Rhiannon states. Audiences today despise Sansa because she
embraces her femininity, but it’s notable that if she was to act like her
sister, Arya Stark who the opposite of their society’s expectation of a women,
Sansa would then be looked down upon by the other characters in the book
because she is different. So, either way no matter how Sansa, Arya, and every
single woman in America acts, they will always be punished for embracing and
rejecting roles expected of women.
Brienne is the exact opposite of
societies explanations of a woman. She wears armor instead of dresses, not very
pretty, and does not have any kids. She is taller, and stronger than most men,
and as a result she is looked at as less of a woman in the book, but a strong
female character in the real world. She is tall, stronger than majority of the
men in the book, and not all that pretty. In “The Women of Game of Thrones:
A Study on Gender Roles” author Angel Wilson talks
about how Brienne is always being picked on by the male characters because they
are not used to seeing a woman act like a man and in the GOT culture it is not
seen as a positive thing. Like Sansa, the audience is not used to seeing a
woman embrace their feminine qualities and is seen as a negative aspect.
There are other characters in the
book that take on the role of a man and are the most loved out of all the
characters and that is Brienne of Tarth and Arya Stark. They push back on what
society wants women to be. Both wear armor instead of dresses and does not care
about their look. They aren’t trying to impress anybody and that’s what makes
them so lovable. Both are seen as strong female characters (a character
that is the total opposite of a damsel in distress character) by the audience
because of how they embrace the characteristics of a male. However, in the book
they are outsiders because they take on the characteristics of a male. Both get
picked on by the men and are treated as if they aren’t females. The hatred that
Sansa, Arya, and Brienne receive shows that no matter women will always be
attacked. Think about how women are compared to men in the real world. When
women excel in traditionally masculine areas such as sports, they are not
valued, just as Brienne and Arya are not valued in Westeros. For example, in
women’s sports like basketball women are paid less, and criticized more.
Whereas men are paid more, more people watch them, and are criticized less.
Women receive no attention or respect when it comes to sports (unless we are
dunking a basketball and that barely gets attention). Women cannot win in both
the GOT culture and reality. We are either hated if we are too girly and
dependent on someone else or hated because we are too masculine and
independent.
Women today don’t want their
identity to be like Sansa, but like Arya. Arya is independent and knows how to
use a sword to protect herself. However, we shouldn’t judge her for being what
society wanted her to be, but instead we should learn to accept feminine
behavior. Being a girly girl doesn’t make you less of a person.
As the series goes on Sansa begins
to evolve and becomes stronger. Instead of getting better with sword skills
like Brienne and Arya, she begins to understand how depend on her feminine
qualities and uses it to protect herself. Most of the audience hates her
because of the way she acted when everything was all lollipops and rainbows in
Winterfell but when things get worse while she is at Kings Landing the way she
acts is not so bad. Before the death of her father Sansa was all for marrying
Joffrey and having his kids, but after her soon to be hubby had her father
beheaded, Sansa begins to change. At one point in the book Joffrey takes Sansa
to the where her father’s head was, and he made her look at it so she will know
what would happen to her if she ever decides to commit treason. She was so
upset with Joffrey that she goes to push him of the bridge they were standing
on, of course she was stopped (I really wish she wasn’t stopped) but at that
moment Sansa’s attitude begins to change.
All societies have expectations for
women, whether it is in the real world or the Game of Thrones world. Both see
women as either to girly or to masculine and as a result of that women can’t
win. The audience’s reaction to these characteristics are because our society
does not value femininity. Why? Because that is how we think as a culture and
that is what we see in our books and a lot of our TV shows/ media, and it needs
to change. Respect Sansa Stark.
- I feel like we had the same opinion of Sansa, and at first when everyone started sharing their opinions about her, I felt like I was the only one who actually liked her. Finally someone understands that she was acting the way she did because of her tradition and how she was raised. Honestly when you said “most loved character in the book yet, the most hated in the real world” and vice versa for Arya and Brienne, I was like why did I not realize that. You gave me an epiphany and it was just described so well. Also, your last sentence was my favorite, they better respect my girl.
ReplyDeleteI think that some women would identify with Sansa's interests, or whatever the modern equivalent of her interests in needle work and dresses are (I for one like fashion myself!). It's important that we don't demonize interests that are traditionally coded as feminine. What I think is problematic about early season Sansa is her belief that she can be totally dependent on Joffrey, a dangerous idea then and now. We should all strive to be independent. The struggle is to recognize the lack of self reliance in Sansa's early years without dismissing all feminine qualities.
ReplyDeleteBB you are completely correct. Why are we, as viewers and readers, angry at Sansa for acting the way society wants her too. She was merely conditioned by society and their fairy tales. We should not take it out on her, but we do. And in the case of Sansa acting like Arya, you hit the nail on the head. No one would bat an eye if she was like Arya, but the whole femininity thing blurs our vision. You answer why society today views the “strong female character” as having male like qualities correctly. BB you present the irony of having a ‘strong female character” that I have never thought about before. The women who are composed of these male like qualities are seen as outsiders in their world, but in ours we embrace them. I never thought of it that way.
ReplyDeleteI am glad you agree with me that if Sansa were to act like Arya, they would not say anything. Like I said in my post the way Sansa acts is not hurting anyone, it is her choice, and no one should be mad about it. I think our society has been brainwashed by our media (how they portray women) to think that women are supposed to be the stay at home moms and cook and clean and do the shopping. But that is not the case and that is where we run into problems with gender roles.
DeleteWOW, I love this different point of view on the way viewers see Sansa. The question you asked, “… shouldn’t we really be angry at the sexist expectations of her society instead of her?” really showed a different point of view. I think this comment really comes back on society now with the way women should act as well. Even though this was supposed to mock the old European days, I think sexism still is a part of our society today.
ReplyDeleteI love the point you make about Brienne and Arya. As a society, we criticize females for being too "girly", but we also criticize them if they are too masculine. Females should be allowed to be whoever they want. No certain characteristics are better than others. No one likes a girly girly, but tomboys are also frowned upon. So, I have one question. Will females actually ever not face criticism?
ReplyDeleteI honestly don't believe that their will be a time when females will not face criticism. There is always going to be that one person (male or female) that will believe that women are supposed to be girly. There is going to be someone that believes women are supposed to be independent. I feel like there will never be a time when someone will see women for who we are and not criticize us by the way we act.
ReplyDelete